How Might We Compare and Contrast Three Early Civilizations?
Girls Preparatory School
Qin Shi Huangdi. Source: Wikipedia at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qin_Shi_Huang#/media/File:Qinshihuang.jpg.
Estimated module length: four to six days
This module was designed for a sixth grade Global Cultures class although it could be implemented in classes ranging from sixth through ninth grade studying history, geography, and culture. Although the module is utilized in a private school, it also includes content that address relevant Tennessee middle school state World History and Geography Standards. Examples include (abridged examples):
6.32 Analyze the influence of geographic features on the origins of ancient Chinese civilization in the Yellow River Valley, and explain how China’s geography helped create a unique yet diverse cultural identity.
6.35 Explain the significance of the unification of ancient China into the first Chinese empire by Qin Shi Huangdi, beginning the Qin Dynasty.
6.25 Identify and locate geographical features of ancient India.
6.26 Explain the emergence of the Harappan civilization in the Indus River Valley as an early agricultural civilization, and describe its achievements.
6.55 Describe the characteristics of Julius Caesar’s rule.
6.56 Analyze the influence of Augustus Caesar, including the establishment of the Roman Empire and its political, geographic, and economic expansion.
Rather than studying this civilization in isolation, this module will allow students to evaluate civilizations comparatively in their own times and in terms of their legacy. In “Teaching Early China and Ancient Rome Comparatively,” Jeffrey Richey argues that to study these cultures is to examine how human beings in widely separated geographical areas coped with similar challenges and circumstances.” This module will provide an opportunity to compare geography, writing systems, government, infrastructure, defense, as well as innovations and contributions.
Students will be able to:
Locate, label, and describe the physical features of the early empires in China and India, as well as the Roman Empire.
Identify and describe the impact of significant accomplishments, developments and innovations from India, China, and Rome.
Consider the type of conclusions that can be drawn and the questions that arise when one examines ancient artifacts.
Examine historical maps from different times and places to compare them to modern maps and analyze the differences between them and the possible reasons for such differences.
Compare and contrast early civilizations using maps, primary sources, and a mini-research assignment.
Students should have experience in using maps, an atlas, and websites to label and add features to maps. They should be familiar with key vocabulary: civilization, legacy, innovation, and empire. It would be helpful if students are experienced with reading and interpreting primary source documents, though it is not assumed that they will be.
This module could be used to frame a thematic approaching to teaching India, Rome, and China, with the teacher framing and filling in the materials with direct instruction and other strategies to provide balanced coverage. The module could also be split into parts, with the brainstorms and geography pieces used before the classroom teacher introduces the student of each civilization. With this approach, the research piece would come at the end of the module and could serve as a wrap-up and assessment. Depending on the teacher preference and intent, prerequisite knowledge will vary.
(five to fifteen minutes, this can be completed individually in notebooks or as a whole class in discussion, depending on time constraints and whether or not you would like students to have a written record of their thoughts)
What makes a civilization or an empire “great?”
How might we learn more about ancient civilizations?
How can you measure the impact of an invention or other accomplishment?
How might we compare and contrast civilizations to better understand their history and legacy?
How did these civilizations interact and how did they view each other?
(eight to ten minutes)
Show some or all of these quick clips to give students a quick look at what they will learn about in this module.
“Indus River Valley Civilization” Two minutes, forty seconds long clip from PBS FIRST CIVILIZATIONS
“The Discovery of the First Chinese Writing” Two minutes, thirty-nine seconds long clip from PBS STORY OF CHINA
Two minutes, twenty-three secongs long trailer from The Roman Empire In The First Century | PBS America clip.
Screen Capture from Indus River Civilization by PBS. Source: https://www.pbs.org/video/indus-valley-civilization-ufdsp9/
Setting the Stage with Maps
Activity 1: Comparing Historical Maps
Use the student handout, Comparing Historical Maps. The handout contains questions for students, content on the relationship between cartography and culture, and three early map: one of the world, one of Rome, and one of China. Students will describe what they see, look for similarities and differences and evidence of different world views and priorities. Students will also record their questions or “wonderings” for use later in the module.
Activity 2: Labeling and Captioning Maps
Students start by thinking about their own home town to describe the ways in which geography might shape a place and determine how people live. They will use Handout 2, Setting the Stage with Maps, for better understanding of the relationship between geography and culture.
Students will then start working on early empire maps China Early Empires, India Early Empires, and Roman Empire 500 AD from the website PHSchool by labeling the cities, bodies of water, mountains deserts, provinces, countries, and continents provided in a list on the student handout. They will then write captions for the italicized items that describe their significance and impact on the early empires.
On the fourth and last map of the world, students will create a key and lightly shade the territories of the empires on one map to see them in relation to each other.
After the labeling, coloring, and captioning is complete, students will revisit the initial brainstorm questions and connect this work to the first map activity.
Historical Borders of China in Four Periods. Source: Asia for Educators at http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/china/geog/M_Hist.htm
Author’s notes on student reactions
Students needed prompting to think specifically about the ancient world given our class is rooted more in the present, however they were much better prepared to think about geography and its impact. They noted location could determine weather and the likelihood of natural disasters like earthquakes, physical features can encourage or limit interactions with other people, it will shape the economy, it relates to safety, it determines architecture, clothing, as well as health and diet.
Day 3 How might we learn more about these civilizations?
Activity 1 -- What can we learn from artifacts?
First distribute the day 3 handout entitled Analyzing Historical Artifacts to the class.
Have the class view the seventeen-minute long TED Talk by Rajesh Rao “A Rosetta Stone for a Lost Language.” where the author, a computer science professor tells the story of his work to decipher the Indus River Valley written script. Before viewing, they should complete two questions, while viewing, they complete several others, and when finished, they use the Creative Questions Visible Thinking routine to examine objects from each of the three civilizations. This activity will provide students with an opportunity to use three museum webpages to look for answers to their questions and to the complete an activity where they will choose a question to imaginatively explore by playing out its possibilities by writing a story or essay, drawing a picture, creating a play or dialogue, inventing a scenario, or conducting an imaginary interview
Days four to five How might we compare the contributions of these civilizations?
In the final comparative civilizations work, students conduct further research on early China, India, and the Roman empire.
Introductory Activity: (15 to 20 minutes in partners, up to a whole class period if the options are projected and the two activities are completed with group participation and explanation of reasons behind proposed rankings.)
Using the Student Research Handout, students will work in pairs to read and discuss a list of innovations and developments so they will be able to rank them in order of their importance to the world.
It would be helpful for students to start by accessing the timeline feature in the Ancient History Encyclopedia. Here students can search by category, by civilization, or by keyword. The timline results include short passages that should provide students with some context to further research the items they have chosen. Similarly, the Directory of the Smith College Museum of Ancient Inventions can provide students with a brief description, time periods, and associated empires for the artifacts that appear in the museum collection (which include several from the list of choices.) The context in these sources will allow students to choose suitable next sources from the Student Sources for Research Activity list provided on page 8.
If available, students will open this Google Doc template to work collaboratively. When they click the link, they will be prompted to make a copy, which they should rename with the student names. The student who saved the document will then share it with their partner so that they may add to it simultaneously. If it is preferable to complete this activity with out access to a device or Google Apps, the template is also provided in a Word Document. Using the template, students will research the items they have chosen and will take notes, in their own words. (Template provided in both Google Doc and Word Document)
Teacher will help students choose one innovation to share with the class so that a wide range of contributions will be covered.
To prepare, students will complete the “I used to think, Now I know, But I still Wonder “protocol to reflect on their prior thoughts.
Presentations should cover their initial thoughts about the importance, when they thought it had been developed, which group or groups they believed to have been responsible for it, and the new information they uncovered in their research.
Each student will look at their initial rankings and decide which changes they would make to their original thoughts, if any. Additionally, students should look back on their “wonderings” throughout the module to see which of their questions have been addressed and which have not.
Choose questions from remaining “wonderings” to research and record findings.
Author’s notes on student reactions
Students needed much more time than expected to rank the items and there were almost no patterns in their responses. Teachers may wish to limit their list to fewer items that our most relevant to your teaching goals or essential questions. In terms of the impact of an event or accomplishment the majority felt it was best measured by the number of people who used it then and continue to use or need it now. Only one student suggested evaluating any changes or shift the invention may have triggered. They were consistently surprised by the contributions of the Harappan Civilization, partly because they had never heard of it and partly because of how early the civilization flourished.
References and Resources:
Jeffrey L. Richey. “Teaching Early China and Ancient Rome Comparatively. “Education About Asia. Volume 13, Number 2. Fall 2008.
Tansen Sen and Victor H. Mair, Tradition China in Asian and World History. Ann Arbor: Association for Asian Studies, Inc., 2012.
Richard H. Davis, Global India circa 100 Ce: South Asia in Early World History. Ann Arbor: Association for Asian Studies, Inc., 2009.
https://www.pbs.org/video/indus-valley-civilization-ufdsp9/: A video on the “Indus River Valley Civilization” from PBS
https://www.pbs.org/video/discovery-first-chinese-writing-0nuw50/: Video on “The Discovery of the First Chinese Writing” from PBS.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jUTjhvgW-zM: “The Roman Empire In The First Century from PBS America on YouTube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0zrLZrlyko: “Chandragupta, Ashoka and the Maurya Empire” by the Khan Academy on YouTube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EZWy7IFBCEQ “Gupta Dynasty” from Khan Academy on YouTube. An overview of accomplishments in India’s golden age.
http://avalon.law.yale.edu/ancient/twelve_tables.asp: The Twelve Tables from Yale University’s Avalon Project.
http://www.cs.colostate.edu/~malaiya/ashoka.html: King Ashoka: His Edicts and His Times from the Colorado State University website.
https://dharma-documentaries.net/the-indus-valley-the-masters-of-the-river “The Indus Valley (The Masters of the River)” on YouTube via the Dharma Documentaries website.
https://www.nytimes.com/2010/09/28/arts/28iht-melvin.html: The New York Times article “Missionary to the Forbidden City” by Sheila Melvin from September 27, 2010.
http://www.henry-davis.com/MAPS/AncientWebPages/AncientL.html: Index of Cartographic Images illustrating maps from the Ancient Period: 6,200 B.C. to 400 A.D. A digital collection of cartographic images sponsored by Henry Davis Consulting
http://cartographic-images.net/Cartographic_Images/115_Strabo.html: Strabo’s World Map from the Henry Davis Consulting cartographic maps collection.
http://www.henry-davis.com/MAPS/AncientWebPages/AncientL.html: Tabula Rogeriana 1154 A.D. Muhammad al-Idrisi. Restored by Konrad Miller in 1927. From the Henry Davis Consulting cartographic maps collection.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pomponius_Mela: Pomponius Mela’s World Map A.D. 37 Reconstruction by Konrad Miller 1898 on Wikipedia.
http://cartographic-images.net/Cartographic_Images/118_Agrippa.html: The Roman Map Reconstruction. Orbis Terrarum A.D. 20. Marcus Vipsanius Agrippa. Reconstruction from Raisz. From the Henry Davis Consulting cartographic maps collection.
http://www.phschool.com/curriculum_support/map_bank/pdfs/China_Early_EmpiresA.pdf: Early Empires in China map from PH School
http://www.phschool.com/curriculum_support/map_bank/pdfs/India_Early_EmpiresA.pdf: Early Empires in India map from PH School
http://www.phschool.com/curriculum_support/map_bank/pdfs/Roman_Empire_500AD_A.pdf: Map of the Roman Empire to 500 AD from PH School
http://www.phschool.com/curriculum_support/map_bank/pdfs/the_world_reliefA.pdf: World Map from PH School
https://www.archives.gov/files/education/lessons/worksheets/written_document_analysis_worksheet_novice.pdf.: Primary Source Analysis Guide by the Library of Congress.
http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/china/geog/maps.htm#1a: Chinese Geography Readings and Maps by Asia for Educators.
http://madefrom.com/history/antiquity/ancient-maps-romans-see-world/: Ancient Maps: How Did Romans See the World? by the Made From website.
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A1999.01.0239%3Abook%3D2%3Achapter%3D5%3Asection%3D17: The Geography of Strabo. Literally translated, with notes, in three volumes. London. George Bell & Sons. 1903. Book II, Chapter 5. Section 17. From the Tufts University Perseus Digital Library
www.loc.gov/item/2007626789/: Idrisi, Approximately, and Konrad Miller. Weltkarte des Idrisi vom Jahrn. Ch., Charta Rogeriana. Stuttgart: Konrad Miller, 1928. Map. Retrieved from the Library of Congress.
http://www.ruf.rice.edu/~asia/CartographyPaper.html Richard J. Smith, Rice University. Mapping China's World: Cultural Cartography in Late Imperial Times. Early World Maps in China.
http://www.gutenberg.org/files/2124/2124-h/2124-h.htm: The Project Gutenberg EBook of Record of Buddhistic Kingdoms, by Fa-Hsien Translator: James Legge
Release Date: March 28, 2006 [Ebook #2124] Last Updated on January 26, 2013
“A Rosetta Stone for a Lost Language.” A TED talk by Rajesh Rao from 2011.
https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/works-of-art/49.40.1/: Image of Stamp Seal and Incense Burner by the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/ht/02/ssa.html: Timeline of Art History by the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
http://www.nationalmuseumindia.gov.in/departments-pre-history.asp?lk=dp1: Prehistory and Archaeology by the National Museum of India.
http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/china/geog/M_Wall.htm: Map Grand Canal and Great Wall by Asia for Educators.
http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/china/geog/maps.htm#2f: Descriptions for Captions of China Map from Asia for Educators
http://www.britishmuseum.org/research/publications/online_research_catalogues/rrc/roman_republican_coins/a_guide_to_types.aspx: The British Museum Guide to Roman Republican Coins.
https://www.nationalgeographic.com/archaeology-and-history/magazine/2016/11-12/roman-aqueducts-engineering-innovation/: Aqueducts: Quenching Rome’s Thirst by National Geographic
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/roman-aqueducts.html: NOVA Watering Ancient Rome by PBS.
https://interestingengineering.com/roman-arch-bridges-weight-hold: Interesting Engineering Roman Arch Bridges: How Much Weight Can They Hold by the Interesting Museum website.
http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/ps/cup/oracle_bone_general.pdf: Oracle Bone Inscriptions of the Late Shang Dynasty from Asia for Educators.
https://tn.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/moveable-type-story-of-china/moveable-type-story-of-china/#.WqaQQZPwagQ: Inventions and Science: Movable Type, The Story of China by PBS Learning Media.
https://tn.pbslearningmedia.org/resource/astronomical-clock-story-of-china/astronomical-clock-story-of-china/: Inventions and Science: Astronomical Clock and Other Advancements, The Story of China by PBS Learning Media
https://www.khanacademy.org/humanities/world-history/world-history-beginnings/ancient-india/a/the-indus-river-valley-civilizations: Indus River Valley civilizations Reading by Khan Academy,
https://china.usc.edu/sites/default/files/forums/Chinese%20Inventions.pdf: Top 20 Ancient Chinese Inventions by the University of Southern California US–China Institute.
http://apworldhistory101.com/history-of-india/gupta/: The Gupta Dynasty of Indian History for AP World History by the AP World History 101 website.